Study skills 6 min read

Describe, analyse or evaluate: how to read the command word in an assessment criterion

Describe, analyse or evaluate: how to read the command word in an assessment criterion
Share this article
Facebook LinkedIn X WhatsApp

Most work that comes back to a learner for a second look is not wrong. It is in the wrong register. The criterion asked the learner to analyse something and they described it instead, accurately, in good English, at length, and it still does not meet the criterion.

That single mismatch separates the learners who finish from the learners who keep resubmitting. It is worth more to you than any amount of advice about highlighter pens.

The command word is the instruction

Every assessment criterion opens with a verb. That verb is not decoration and it is not a synonym chosen for variety. It sets the depth of thinking the awarding organisation will accept, and an assessor cannot waive it, because we mark against the criterion's own words.

Command wordWhat it asks forWhat does not meet it
Identify, state, listName the thing, correctlyLittle goes wrong here
Describe, explainAn accurate account, with the how and the whyA heading with nothing under it
Analyse, examine, compareThe parts, and how they bear on each otherA list, which holds no relations
Evaluate, assess, justifyStrengths weighed against weaknesses, and your own judgementAn account of how it turned out
Demonstrate, carry out, manageYou doing it at work, with the record that proves itWhat you would do

The last row catches the most people. A criterion that says demonstrate asks for the thing itself, so a description of good practice is evidence that you have read about it.

The same point, written three ways

Take an ordinary situation. A small office kept a paper visitor book at reception, a fire drill showed that nobody could say who was in the building, and the office bought a tablet with a sign-in app for the reception desk.

As description

We used to record visitors in a paper book at reception. Each one wrote their name, their company, the time they arrived and who they were visiting, and signed out on the way home. After a fire drill in March the roll call did not match the people in the car park, so we replaced the book with a tablet running a sign-in app, which the fire marshal can read from a phone.

That is an accurate account, and it meets a criterion that says describe. It would not meet one that says analyse, because nothing in it says why the paper book failed.

As analysis

The paper book failed at the one moment it was needed, and the reason was where it sat rather than what it was. Reception is on the front door, so visitors signed the book and contractors came in through the yard gate and never saw it. It also depended on people signing out, which they did through reception and did not when they left by the side door for the car park. The register was therefore wrong in two directions at once, holding people who had gone and missing people who had arrived.

Moving the record onto a tablet changed the medium and neither cause. It still sits on the front desk and still relies on the visitor choosing to use it, so the register is only as good as the one door it watches.

That took the thing apart and showed how one part acted on another. No judgement has been made about whether the tablet was worth buying, which is correct, because analysis is not the place for it.

A list of your priorities is description. Which one you dropped, and why, is analysis.

As evaluation

The tablet was the right buy for the fire register and a poor buy for the problem underneath it. Against the fault we had it is a clear improvement, because the marshal can read the list from the car park and the paper book made that impossible once the building was empty. It is better for data protection too: the open book showed every previous visitor's name and employer to whoever signed next.

Set against the cost, it is weaker. It did nothing about the yard gate, and a sign there with a second terminal would have cost less than the app's annual licence. My judgement is that we keep the tablet and treat the gate as unfinished work rather than report the problem as solved, because the next drill will fail in the same direction if we do not.

How we mark it, so you know what you are being read for

Our assessors tag every criterion with the kind of demand it makes, taken from its wording and never from how well the work is written. The categories are descriptive, analytical and evaluated, plus not met where the evidence does not carry the criterion at all.

Your feedback then names each criterion in turn and says what your evidence does and does not show against it. Where it is not met, you are told which demand the criterion makes and which one the work currently meets, because that is the gap you can act on. Feedback here also carries a spelling, punctuation and grammar section every time, quoting your own words with the correction beside them, and an error there never changes a criterion verdict on its own.

Two things make this safe to get wrong. Study is at your own pace, so no assignment on our virtual learning environment carries a due date, and every one of them accepts unlimited attempts. A piece of work in the wrong register costs you a redraft and nothing else.

Where AI makes this harder

Generative AI writes fluent description. Ask it to analyse and you will usually get a longer, more confident description with the word "analysis" in the opening line, which is the failure this article is about with better grammar hiding it.

Each of our assignment briefs states the level of AI use allowed for that task, and on an OTHM qualification the level sits in the task instructions on the virtual learning environment. You declare what you used at our AI use declaration. Using AI inside the level the brief allows is permitted; not declaring it is what causes a problem.

What to do on your own course this week

Open the brief for the unit you are working on and find the criterion you are about to write against. Copy it into your document above your own words and circle the verb. Then read your paragraph and ask which verb it performs. If the criterion says analyse and your paragraph recounts what happened in order, you have found the gap before your assessor did.

Then swap the name. Could your paragraph be true of any other organisation, with its name changed? If it could, it is almost certainly description, because analysis lives in the particular relations inside your own workplace. Where the criterion says evaluate, look for the sentence in which you choose and say why. If it is not there, the criterion is not met yet, whatever else is on the page.

Our piece on portfolio assessment covers what "no exams" means in practice over a whole unit, and our piece on Functional Skills English is worth reading if writing at the level is the part you find hardest.

If you want to study this formally, our NCFE Level 3 Diploma for Business Administrators is a regulated qualification you can start online at any time, assessed on criteria written exactly this way. Our NCFE Level 3 Diploma in Skills for Business: Human Resources is built the same way.

Found this useful? Share it
Facebook LinkedIn X WhatsApp

Before you pay for a course

A free guide: how to check in five minutes that a qualification is genuinely regulated, the seven questions to ask any provider including us, and what your fee should actually buy. Enter your email and we will send you a confirmation link. Confirm it and the guide is yours, along with an email whenever we publish something new. No spam, unsubscribe any time.